The Great Pizza Company

The Great Pizza Company, nestled in the heart of downtown Eustis, Florida, is a cherished gem for pizza aficionados craving authentic New York-style pies with an artisan touch. Celebrating over 14 years of culinary passion, this cozy pizzeria delivers a truly memorable dining experience that feels like a slice of New York right in Lake County.

From the moment you step inside, the inviting aroma of freshly baked thin-crust pizzas envelops you, setting the stage for what’s to come. The Great Pizza Company’s menu is a flavorful journey through classic and inventive pizzas that cater to every palate. Signature dishes like the Pepperoni Pizza with Extra Pepperoni captivate with perfectly crisp edges and a symphony of savory, spiced toppings. For the adventurous, the Thai Chicken Pizza offers an intriguing fusion of tangy and spicy flavors that dance on the tongue, while the playful Garbage Pizza serves up a delightful medley of toppings that never fails to impress.

Adventurers in customization will savor the Build Your Own Pizza option, where hand-tossed dough forms the perfect canvas for a personalized masterpiece. Complementing these pizzas are exquisite starters like the Garlic Knots — golden, buttery bites laced with fragrant garlic — and the irresistible Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks that perfectly balance crispness with rich, cheesy goodness.

But it’s not just about pizza here. The Great Pizza Company offers a robust selection of appetizers including crispy Fried Green Beans, tangy Pork Egg Rolls, and hearty Chicken Wings that set the table for a truly fulfilling meal. Don’t miss the decadent Fried Cheesecake “Little Taste of Heaven”, a dessert that effortlessly melts away into buttery sweetness, a perfect endcap to your meal.

The beverages are just as thoughtfully curated. Their Cold Brew with Sweet Cream Foam delivers a smooth, refreshing lift, balancing boldness with a creamy finish that perfectly complements the rich flavors of the food.

What truly elevates the experience, beyond the exceptional food, is the warm, family-run atmosphere. Owner Sandy’s welcoming nature shines through, making every guest feel like an honored visitor. Many patrons recall feeling embraced by her genuine hospitality, creating a friendly vibe that lingers long after the last slice is gone. From the attentive service to the limited but charming outdoor seating, dining here is cozy, comfortable, and quietly sophisticated.

Customers regularly praise the Great Pizza Company for its authentic New York-style crust — thin, crispy, yet tender — and abundant, flavorful toppings. Reviews mention the nostalgic ambiance reminiscent of the Dumbo neighborhood’s pizza havens, reinforcing the restaurant’s commitment to quality and tradition. Whether you’re drawn by the Chipotle Chicken Pizza or the mouthwatering Sausage and Onion specialties, each bite is a testament to care and craftsmanship.

In all, The Great Pizza Company offers more than just a meal; it offers a heartfelt connection to pizza culture deeply rooted in passion and expertise. This is not merely a place to eat — it’s a community hub where food love and genuine hospitality come together, making every visit something to savor, reminisce about, and eagerly anticipate returning to.